[ Return to APA Home Page ]

Guidelines for Submissions

APA NEWSLETTERS
    American Indians
        Viola F. Cordova &
        Anne Waters, Co-Editors
    Black Experience
        Jesse Taylor, Editor
   
Philosophy and Computers
        Jon Dorbolo, Editor
    Feminism and Philosophy
        Joan Callahan, Editor
    Hispanic/Latino Issues in
    Philosophy
        Eduardo Mendieta, Editor
    Philosophy and Law
        Richard Nunan, Editor
    Philosophy and Lesbian,
    Gay, Bisexual and
    Transgender Issues
        Timothy Murphy, Editor
    Philosophy and Medicine
        Rosamond Rhodes, Editor
    Teaching Philosophy
        Tziporah Kasachkoff &
        Eugene Kelly, Co-Editors

Navigation
   
Newsletters Index (00:2)
    apaOnline Home Page

 

APA Newsletters

Spring 2001
Volume 00, Number 2


Newsletter on American Indians in Philosophy

Book Reviews

Previous Article | Index | Next Article


Gerald Mohatt & Joseph Eagle Elk. The Price of a Gift: A Lakota Healer's Story.
Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2000. 236 + xiv pp. Illustrations, photographs, notes, index.

Reviewed by Anne Waters, J.D., Ph.D.

This outstanding new book is about Joe Eagle Elk (1931-1991) and Lakota ways of healing, about tiospaye (extended family of birth and nurture), and its foundation, mitakuye oyas'in (all my relatives). This is the spiritual place from which Joseph Eagle Elk struggles to be a good relative and fulfill his family duties as a healer to all generations.

In this book, Gerald Mohatt has put into transcript the tape recordings of Joe talking about his life; also included are transcripts from recordings of people Joe has healed. The current of this book flows through interstices of time and space, as we learn about personal healing, the life of a healer, and a traditional Ndn relationship between healer and healed.

Joe enables people to understand the deep meaning of our abilities to call forth our animal and plant helpers in the process of becoming grounded in our places of being. This is accomplished via four traditional powers: heyoka; wanagi, yuwipi, and tahca. Joe was born with a tawacin (purpose) of being a healer. Until he accepts this role, he wanders in life, having a recurring dream. This dream is a gift to help Joe find his way of sincerity and respect among the Lakota, to find his home, that place to which he (we) keep returning. The life Joe lives is a life of prayer, sacrifice, healing, and thanking. His stregth is continually renewed in vision quests and sun dances, where he remembers himself equal with the two leggeds, four leggeds, winged ones, and all of plant life. Joe lives the life of Lakota Oyate (the people), a life of patience, acceptance, understanding, and spirituality. From the songs of the heart, he knows who he is, where he comes from, and that he is never alone.

The strength of humor, the medicine of talking (p. 79) in the right way, with care and respect, the art of listening, and the talent of vision are the inner tools of Joe's gift of healing. In the book we follow the imagery of Joe's world as he tells it to Mohatt. From his difficulties with the law, the years away from home working, his symbolic encounter with his eventual friend, the eagle, and finally, meeting his spiritual thunder power helpers, heyoka zik'ala and heyoka isnala (97).

Intrinsic to understanding Joe's stories of healing is the belief that medicines (plants, herbs, etc.) are people, are relatives. Allowing our hurt and pain to leave our bodies means the medicine has become our friend and that we can work together getting to know one another, in order to heal our body. In this way we need to create a good relationship with everything that goes inside our body. To be healed human persons take on the responsibility of working together with the medicine people by thinking deeply about medicines, body, and healing. There is an especially helpful section in this book when an anonymous person talks about Joe's thunder power and its use. The person tells us that "Joe compared the creation and use of electricity with his own power that he received from the thunder beings (133, 134)."

Once Joe has accepted his place, his gift of human healing, he never questions his purpose. He learns to incorporate healing powers: of serious laughter in recognizing that we pick our home, our communities (171); of family story, bringing the community together through the ordinariness of being, in past, present, and future as one in community; of the ceremonial and community time web found in the symbolic synergy that merges place, meal, prayer, and spirituality; of reciprocity when empowering people, knowing that his work takes in the community and goes beyond himself; and of the intellectual truth of contraries, the ritual clowns that present to us our authenticity of Being.

It is very difficult to step outside the infrastructure of one metaphysical system to experience another. Yet Joe Eagle Elk comfortably renders a way of thinking about an indigenous metaphysical infrastructure, that the reader can grasp in theory (eg. the syntactical meaning of "all my relations"); he paints a picture of the praxis of living the infrastructure. In this way an indeterminate semantics of language opens up for the reader, and this opening up allows for an intellectual "closeness" to the infrastucture.

The mediative process of Joe, as healer, bonds patients with a new metaphysics; and in the communicative process, moves toward the purpose of self healing. In this way the healer is a teacher, a guide, and an enabler in the path from dependency upon healer, through autonomy of self healing, to finally discovering an authenticity of being (in harmony) among "all my relations."

Joe Eagle Elk live a life of moral dimensions, a life of giving and receiving, a life of transcending the dominant linear and material culture of our time. I recommend this book to anyone interested in a native worldview, and to anyone wanting to explore the meaning of "indigenous healing."


Previous Article | Index | Next Article


Copyright 2000, The American Philosophical Association.
Last revised: August 28, 2001